Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) Practice Co-Chair Jason Fitzsimmons spoke with World IP Review about the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office’s (USPTO) return of some decision-making authority to PTAB judges for patents up for review.

Fitzsimmons commented, “Director Squires stated in his recent Congressional testimony that he intended to return merits decisions to the board, so it seemed not to be a question of ‘if’ but rather ‘when.’” He added, “The workload of determining all aspects of institution decisions also seemed to be unsustainable long-term, as the director has many other matters within his purview at the office beyond PTAB institution decisions.”

This change will require petitioners and patent owners to navigate another adjustment period. Fitzsimmons said that both petitioners and patent owners will generally welcome the fact that administrative law judges must explain the merits-based considerations in institution decisions, but do not need to address every challenged claim, ground or argument.

In a recent Sterne Kessler client alert, it was noted that the change is “good news for patent owners,” who now have a greater chance of defeating institution on the merits. However, for petitioners, strong and comprehensive petitions are more important than ever. Fitzsimmons said, “Based on the institution considerations in the director’s memo, petitioners need airtight, element-by-element mapping to the prior art.”

He also notes, “They should also carefully consider whether to include marginal claims in a petition, since weak challenges across a number of claims could sink the whole petition under the ‘substantial majority’ of claims guidelines.”

Fitzsimmons added that previously, patent owners rarely addressed dependent claims in preliminary responses before institution, “But with the guideline that the PTAB should deny institution if a petitioner fails to make the requisite showing for a ‘substantial majority’ of the challenged claims, I expect to see patent owners making arguments for dependent claims more frequently.”

Fitzsimmons believes it is “too early to say” whether institution rates will increase or decrease but explained that there has already been an upward trend in recent months. “However, the guidelines contain some favorable factors for patent owners, most notably that if the evidence and arguments for and against unpatentability of a claim are in equipoise, the PTAB will view that as the petitioner not having met its burden.”